Wednesday, April 13, 2016

How Germany reformed its labor markets

It's relative but the change Germany has undergone is remarkable (CityJournal):

Prompted by Hartz’s analysis and a clear record of economic failure, Germany’s socialist government asked him to lead the newly formed Commission for Modern Labor Market Services.

At some political risk, the government quickly adopted the group’s recommended pro-market reforms. To give firms more flexibility, Germany slashed labor regulations, making it easier to fire and lay off workers—and far less risky to hire new ones. Allowing labor contracts to settle on a firm-by-firm basis, rather than insisting on a national settlement, the government empowered individual firms to adjust to changing economic conditions. Another reform gave management more freedom to hire temporary workers and write fixed-term contracts with individuals, introducing flexibility into management decision-making and further reducing the risks of hiring.

The Hartz reforms set quantitative goals for placing the unemployed in jobs and authorized unemployment offices to serve as temporary work agencies. As a further spur to job placements, the new system encourages unemployment offices to use private-placement services, which job-seekers pay for using government-issued vouchers. Perhaps most significantly, the reforms ended the old system’s no-questions-asked benefit system. The new system focuses on what reformers call “rights and duties.” The unemployed can collect full benefits for six to 12 months, but after that, the able-bodied are obliged to enroll in training programs and take any “suitable work” offered. Failure to comply could cost them all or some of their benefits. Disabled and older workers can get stipends to compensate for declines in pay, but they must work to get them, and the payments diminish over time. Similar stipends are available to unemployed workers looking to start new businesses, provided their plans pass muster with the local chamber of commerce.

In good Teutonic fashion, the government has rigorously monitored outcomes. More than 20 research institutions and 100 researchers have worked on the reform project, and—remarkably, for anything in the political-economic realm—independent research, detailed econometric work, and qualitative institutional assessments have all judged the reforms to be successful. An independent assessment by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) concurs. Since the Hartz measures took effect in 2005, the German economy has closed the growth gap with its global competitors. And at 4.5 percent, Germany’s unemployment rate is lower than that of every other major Western economy.

No comments: